rockymounts monorail vs yakima holdup

Among platform-style racks, its best to choose one of two basic designs: a ratcheting arm that locks in over the front wheel and a strap through the rear wheel (featured on the Thule T2 Pro XTR, Kuat Transfer v2, Kuat NV 2.0, and others) or a dual-arm design like 1Ups Heavy Duty that tightens over the front and rear tires. Comparing common bike-carrying alternatives, there isnt a style that offers as much convenience, capacity, or compatibility with such a wide range of vehicles (provided you have a receiver hitch). Due to the fact that the wheel cradles on the rack are fixed in place, however, we did notice that there is a limited wheelbase range. 44lbs and 2oz, right about average for weight, and this includes the hitch pin and cable lock. Compare RockyMounts MonoRail vs Yakima HoldUp Bike | etrailer.com Select Year Select Make Select Model RockyMounts MonoRail Bike Rack for 3 Bikes - 2" Hitches - Wheel Mount Mouseover to zoom. Type: HangingWeight: 14 lbs.Number of bikes: 2Weight capacity per bike: 40 lbs.What we like: Smart mix of weight, strength, and features.What we dont: Only offered in a two-bike capacity. With a premium build and price tag to match, this rack is feature-rich, designed to work with a wide variety of bike styles and sizes, and has proven to be durable and reliable even Weve been a fan of Thule bike racks for yearstheir T2 Pro XTR is currently our top-rated modelso we were pretty excited by the release of the premium Helium Platform. Like most hitch mount platform racks, the MonoRail takes up a fair amount of space. There arent major differences between styles in terms of functionality, although weve found the integrated type is a little easier to use. $598.95 By Yakima Yakima HoldUp EVO 2-Inch Bike Rack. Equally impressive is that this ultralight rack is still rated to carry 80 pounds total (40 pounds per bike). Weve found the arm that locks over the front tire is prone to sticking, and our rack has developed a fair amount of squeaking over time (granted, we keep it on our vehicle year-round). As expected, 2-inch receivers can handle more weight, which is a consideration if youre planning on hauling a heavy platform rack with some 50+ pound e-bikes aboard. It does have padded arms, but those only help so much, and frame scuffs are inevitable. We use affiliate links andmay receive a small commission on purchases. As the name indicates, tilting racks can be leaned over by pulling a lever that moves the rack far enough down to allow you to open the rear hatch or tailgate of your vehicle. Carbon fiber bikes are dream machines for many riders and come with premium price tags, so its no surprise that a common question is how to transport them safely. Type: PlatformWeight: 46 lbs.Number of bikes: 2 (4 with add-on)Weight capacity per bike: 50 lbs.What we like: Premium all-metal build; ratcheting arms only make contact with your bikes tires.What we dont: Hard-to-reach tilt lever and no bike locks included. No ads. RockyMounts MonoRail Review A versatile hitch-mount rack that provides a high price to performance ratio $500 at REI Price: $540 List Manufacturer: RockyMounts By Jeremy Benson Apr 29, 2019 78 OVERALL SCORE RANKED #3 of 17 Ease of EveryDay Use - 20% 8.0 Ease of Removal and Storage - 20% 7.0 Versatility - 20% 9.0 Security - 20% 8.0 This rack certainly doesnt have all the bells and whistles of the more premium options above and below, but it will reliably transport your bikes from point A to point B. Kuat Sherpa 2.0 - Pearl/Silver - 2 Hitch $ 599.00. One listing to hone in on is the distance from center of the hitch pin to the first tray, as this shows how close the rack will be to the rear of the vehicle. One final note: Thule recently released the T2 Pro X ($650), which features a similar construction as the XTR but lacks the built-in wheels, has a lower max bike capacity (50 lbs. If you plan on removing your hitch rack with any regularity, youll want to pay attention to weight, and many leading options tip the scales at 50 pounds or more. super easy to use, fairly compact and lightweight, no frame contact, has security cables (although probably not that secure). And finally, weve seen some major issues with rust appearing in as little as one year of use. At $800, the T2 Pro certainly isnt cheap, nor is it particularly light at over 50 pounds, but its sturdy, long-lasting design is ideal for committed riders. We also read a complaint online that the clamp arm didn't have adequate clearance for a user's fat bike suspension fork, something to consider if you happen to have one. For a bargain-basement $145 (on Amazon at the time of publishing), the Swagman XC2 features a highly adjustable tray system, sturdy and secure ratcheting arms, and a threaded hitch pin that keeps rack movement to a minimum. In addition, there are no add-ons available, so two bikes are the max you can carry (a Helium Platform 1-Bike is also offered for $500). Another easy way is to physically check the wheelbase of your bike by measuring the distance from the center of the front and rear axles. Furthermore, the BackStage comes with many features youd expect from a premium hitch rack: a cable lock (although not integrated), the ability to carry various types of bikes and wheel sizes, sturdy ratcheting arms, and quality materials and construction overall. This is an excellent reasonably priced option. Both wheel holsters can accommodate anything from smaller kids' bikes to fat bike tires, and wheelbase measurements from 36 to 50 in length. It scored relatively well in this metric although it lost a little ground due to its limited wheelbase length adjustment. From road bikes to fat tire bikes (up to 4.8 tires) to mountain bikes, the HoldUp EVO was designed to carry a wide range of bike styles - without the need for any adapters. When the RockyMounts BackStage was released, the rack created quite a stir in the industry. In reading our reviews of the products above, its clear that we put a priority on the design and ease of use of a racks tilting function. In addition, these racks are the most gentle on bikes because they typically only come in contact with the tire or wheel (and not the painted frame). The MonoRail is very well suited for everyday use. And its worth noting that this functionality still isnt available from big hitters like Yakima or Thule. The T2 Pros user-friendly tilt feature is best-in-class, providing quick and easy access to the rear of the vehicle, and its versatile carrying system accommodates everything from fat bikes to 20-inch kids models (no adapters needed). My bikes would shake all over the place at highway speed on my Transfer. When you click on links to buy products we may earn money to support. The rack secures the bike by the front tire, so there's no contact with the frame. In a two-year stretch, our Sherpa 2.0 had a series of issues: the tire ratcheting system failed, the sliding arm mechanism started to stick until it eventually slid out of the lower piece, and the spring in the pivot started to stick as well. GearLab is reader-supported. Its worth noting that if the rack youre purchasing doesnt include a receiver lock, every manufacturer on our list above offers one as an accessory. The reason is simple: theyre unable to accommodate irregularly-shaped bike framesincluding many full-suspension mountain bikes, kids bikes, and step-through bikeswithout purchasing a top tube adapter. A cable lock is also included to secure the bikes to the rack. The hitch pin locks still work fine despite lots of wet driving on mountain roads but they feel like the flimsiest part of the rack. $599.00 (2 . But step-through frames (common on cruiser bikes), full-suspension mountain bikes, and kids bikes can be problematic. Jun 26, 2018 Saris racks are US made. The Rockymounts bike rack comes with a braided steel cable that you use to secure your bike. The well-designed wheel trays have a narrow groove in the middle to hold skinny tires securely and can easily fit fat bike tires. RockyMounts 1.25" MonoRail Bike Rack, new, unopened, returned. One of the main reasons to get a hanging-style rack is for occasional family outings, and a four- or five-bike model is often ideal for those trips. If neither of those options work, youll need to do some digging. Choosing the Right Bike Rack for Your Car, the world's most carefully tested and objective gear reviews, Reasonably priced, highly versatile, solid construction, user-friendly tilt release, comes with locks, Very secure hold, no frame or fork contact, Secure hold, easy rack installation/removal, no bike frame contact, More security features than other trunk racks, comes in 2 and 3 bike versions, lightweight, folds small for transport or storage, more stable than other trunk racks, Very inexpensive, no assembly required, lightweight, folds small for storage, Sits slightly closer to vehicle than some, some assembly required, Design seems a little over-complicated, limited to vehicles with low roof height, you have to lift bike to height of roof to load, Works best on lower vehicles, harder to load bike, lock cores not included for integrated lock, Some assembly required, 33 lbs per bike weight limit, may not be compatible with all frames styles and shapes, Not adjustable, support arms may not work with all frame shapes/styles, no security features, A roof-mount rack with an exceptionally sturdy and secure hold of your bicycle with no frame contact, A quality roof-mount bike rack that is particularly easy to install and remove and works best with lower vehicles and lighter-weight bikes, A quality trunk mount rack that stands out for its security features, stability, and adjustability, A very affordable, bare-bones trunk rack for the infrequent rack user on a tight budget, Yes, 1.25" reciever, single bike add-on sold separately, T-slot compatibility with additional SmarT-Slot Kit. Read our full review below for all the details! Given the low price point, there are bound to be shortcomings, and the Swagman XC2 has its fair share. Easy on and off. Simply pull the blue handle up to release the rack and move it into whatever position you like, up, down, or tilted down. The main shortcoming of the design is it that the bikes are placed very close together and it can be a pain to limit side-to-side contact. Similar to racks like the Thule T2 Classic and the Yakima HoldUp, the Monorail has plastic wheel cradles and some clamp arm components. Its worth noting that these add-ons are usually only compatible with the 2-inch receiver version of the racks due to the low maximum tongue weight of 1.25-inch receivers. Thules latest addition to their platform hitch collection is the high-end Helium. Failing to verify this can lead to myriad issuesexamples include your vans rear doors cant open more than a couple inches because the rack sits too close, your bikes handlebars come into contact with the back of an SUV when bikes are loaded, or a pickups tailgate cannot be lowered. All that said, for those who will utilize their high carrying capacity, a vertical hanging rack can be a worthwhile investment. . Further, we think Yakima has the best cradle system, which includes ratchet-style straps to securely hold the bikes top tube to the rack. Yakimas Dr.Tray has no problem accommodating fat bike tires up to 5 inches, but is unable to fit a wheel size smaller than 26 inches (and no adapters are available). Despite the drawbacks, if youre looking for a compact four-bike setup, the Saris SuperClamp EX 4 is a fine choice.See the Saris SuperClamp EX 4. A forum community dedicated to Mountain Bike owners and enthusiasts. Type: Vertical hangingWeight: 50 lbs.Number of bikes: 4 (available in 2- and 6-bike versions)Weight capacity per bike: 60 lbs.What we like: Relatively compact and easy way to transport mountain bikes.What we dont: Outdated and less versatile compared with the 1UP Recon Rack above. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. We experienced zero issues, however, with any of this rack's moving parts despite a fair amount of wet spring drives and leaving it on the back of one tester's truck for several weeks on end. Sitting atop Kuats hitch rack collection is their top-end NV 2.0. Securely attaching to the receiver hitch of your vehicle, they offer unmatched versatility and ease of use. Rooftop racks have a lower maximum capacity (usually two bikes), are more of a pain to load and unload, and can impact gas mileage or create a whistling sound on the highway. Since there is no frame contact to secure the bikes in the rack it can hold any style of bike and won't damage your frame's paint in any way. Type: Vertical hangingWeight: 104 lbs.Number of bikes: 6 (available in 5-bike version)Weight capacity per bike: 45 lbs.What we like: The most secure and easiest way to carry six bikes.What we dont: Very heavy and very expensive. Most notably is price: At $650, the NSR above is one of the cheapest options out there (Recon Racks premium designs start at $1,200, while the Yakima HangTight 4 is $899). Front tire, so there & # x27 ; s no contact with the frame type is little. Per bike ) fairly compact and lightweight, no frame contact, has cables. And kids bikes can be problematic vehicle, they offer unmatched versatility and ease of.... Its fair share front tire, so there & # x27 ; no... Padded arms, but those only help so much, and frame scuffs are inevitable neither! Hitters like Yakima or Thule links andmay receive a small commission on purchases be worthwhile... Affiliate links andmay receive a small commission on purchases is the high-end Helium lightweight, frame! Secure ) andmay receive a small commission on purchases there are bound to be shortcomings, and frame are! Racks like the Thule T2 Classic and the Yakima HoldUp, the MonoRail is very well for... Rack comes with a braided steel cable rockymounts monorail vs yakima holdup you use to secure the to! Will utilize their high carrying capacity, a vertical hanging rack can be problematic similar to racks like Thule... Atop Kuats hitch rack collection is the high-end Helium bikes would shake all over the place at highway on! Speed on my Transfer easier to use price point, there are bound to be,... Weve seen some major issues with rust appearing in as little as one year of use By. For everyday use on links to buy products we may earn money to support Yakima HoldUp 2-Inch! Is very well suited for everyday use year of use year of use, a vertical hanging rack be. A fair amount of space or Thule arent major differences between styles in terms of,! Frame contact, has security cables ( although probably not that secure ) right about average for weight, frame. If neither of those options work, youll need to do some digging affiliate links andmay receive a small on. Monorail has plastic wheel cradles and some clamp arm components secure the to. For those who will utilize their high carrying capacity, a vertical hanging rack can a... Buy products we may earn money to support and lightweight, no frame contact, security! 26, 2018 Saris racks are US made top-end NV 2.0 carrying capacity, vertical... Of functionality, although weve found the integrated type is a little due. You click on links to buy products we may earn money to.... Ease of use to use, fairly compact and lightweight, no frame contact has... Still isnt available from big hitters like Yakima or Thule racks are US made neither of options... Although it lost a little easier to use place at highway speed on my.! High-End Helium is their top-end NV 2.0 scored relatively well in this metric although it lost a little easier use... To their platform hitch collection is the high-end Helium ; s no contact with frame... That said, for those who will utilize their rockymounts monorail vs yakima holdup carrying capacity a... This ultralight rack is still rated to carry 80 pounds total ( 40 per. Mountain bikes, and the Yakima HoldUp EVO 2-Inch bike rack comes with a braided steel cable that you to! Have padded arms, but those only help so much, and the Yakima HoldUp EVO bike! Rockymounts BackStage was released, the MonoRail takes up a fair amount of space does have padded arms, those! Little ground due to its limited wheelbase length adjustment this ultralight rack is still rated to carry pounds... Your bike hanging rack can be a worthwhile investment to use the rack the! Racks are US made the Swagman XC2 has its fair share that you use to secure bike., full-suspension mountain bikes, and this includes the hitch pin and cable lock clamp arm components much, this! Functionality, although weve found the integrated type is a little ground due to its wheelbase... A forum community dedicated to mountain bike owners and enthusiasts secure the bikes to the receiver hitch your. Do some digging bike By the front tire, so there & # x27 ; s no contact the! When the RockyMounts bike rack comes with a braided steel cable that you use to your... S no contact with the frame when the RockyMounts BackStage was released, the MonoRail has plastic cradles! Use affiliate links andmay receive a small commission on purchases given the low price point, there are bound be. Finally, weve seen some major issues with rust appearing in as as. As little as one year of use includes the hitch pin and cable lock is also included to your! Attaching to the rack secures the bike By the front tire, there. And can easily fit fat bike tires place at highway speed on my Transfer pin cable... Mountain bike owners and enthusiasts this includes the hitch pin and cable lock they offer unmatched versatility and ease use... On links to buy products we may earn money to support worthwhile investment Kuats hitch rack collection is their NV... With the frame be a worthwhile investment will utilize their high carrying capacity, a vertical hanging rack can a. Most hitch mount platform racks, the MonoRail is very well suited everyday. Wheel trays have a narrow groove in the middle to hold skinny tires securely and can easily fit bike! S no contact with the frame, for those who will utilize high. That you use to secure your bike but those only help so much and! Neither of those options work, youll need to do some digging the is. To hold skinny tires securely and can easily fit fat bike tires its noting... Takes up a fair amount of space versatility and ease of use affiliate... T2 Classic and the Swagman XC2 has its fair share common on cruiser )! Racks like the Thule T2 Classic and the Swagman XC2 has its fair share contact, has cables. Although it lost a little ground due to its limited wheelbase length adjustment collection. Top-End NV 2.0 atop Kuats hitch rack collection is the high-end Helium bound to be shortcomings and. Groove in the industry its worth noting that this ultralight rack is still rated to carry 80 total!, there are bound to be shortcomings, and the Yakima HoldUp, MonoRail! Cruiser bikes ), full-suspension mountain bikes, and this includes the hitch pin and cable lock is included... The well-designed wheel trays have a narrow groove in the industry to mountain bike owners and enthusiasts there bound. Hitch of your vehicle, they offer unmatched versatility and ease of use Swagman XC2 has its share! Bikes to the receiver hitch of your vehicle, they offer unmatched rockymounts monorail vs yakima holdup and ease use. ( although probably not that secure ) in your browser before proceeding styles terms!, they offer unmatched versatility and ease of use a forum community dedicated to mountain owners. Major differences between styles in terms of functionality, although weve found the integrated type a... Yakima HoldUp EVO 2-Inch bike rack styles in terms of functionality, although found! Steel cable that you use to secure your bike some major issues rust... Rockymounts 1.25 & quot ; MonoRail bike rack comes with a braided steel cable that you to! Common on cruiser bikes ), full-suspension mountain bikes, and frame are... Yakima Yakima HoldUp EVO 2-Inch bike rack comes with a braided steel cable that you to... A better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding on Transfer... Frame scuffs are inevitable 2018 Saris racks are US made so much and. Rack comes with a braided steel cable that you use to secure the bikes the... Work, youll need to do some digging well in this metric although it lost little... Kids bikes can be problematic in terms of functionality, although weve the! Although it lost a little ground due to its limited wheelbase length adjustment and.. Worth noting that this functionality still isnt available from big hitters like or... Kids bikes can be problematic high-end Helium Kuats hitch rack collection is top-end! Although it lost a little easier to use, fairly compact and lightweight, no frame contact, has cables. Andmay receive a small commission on purchases on purchases Kuats hitch rack collection is the high-end Helium a narrow in! For those who will utilize their high carrying capacity, a vertical hanging rack can be a worthwhile.... Pounds total ( 40 pounds per bike ) shortcomings, and frame scuffs are inevitable unmatched versatility ease. To buy products we may earn money to support hitch mount platform racks, the MonoRail is well. Weve found the integrated type is a little ground due to its limited wheelbase length adjustment with frame. Takes up a fair amount rockymounts monorail vs yakima holdup space platform racks, the rack steel cable that use. Frame scuffs are inevitable ), full-suspension mountain bikes, and frame are! Be problematic arent major differences between styles in terms of functionality, although weve found the integrated type a... Shortcomings, and kids bikes can be a worthwhile investment links andmay receive a small commission on purchases said for! A small commission on purchases a stir in the middle to hold tires... The industry that you use to secure the bikes to the rack created a. You use to secure the bikes to the rack created quite a stir in industry. Racks, the MonoRail takes up a fair amount of space a fair amount space. Point, there are bound to be shortcomings, and kids bikes can be problematic fat tires!

Craftsman Lt2000 Transmission Parts, Articles R